Which Deadly Sin
Definitions

Deadly sin or mortal sin?

Two different systems, one shared word. A deadly sin is a habit; a mortal sin is a single act that crosses a line - and you can have one without the other.

This is the most common piece of confusion about the whole subject, and it comes from a single word doing two jobs. Deadly in "seven deadly sins" and mortal in "mortal sin" are not describing the same thing, and the two systems were built for different purposes.

Two systems, not one

The seven deadly sins are a list of habits. Pride, greed, lust, envy, gluttony, wrath and sloth are dispositions - patterns of wanting that shape a life over decades. The older name for them is capital sins, from the Latin caput, a head or source, because the other faults were thought to grow out of them.

A mortal sin is a single act, assessed case by case. It is a legal and pastoral category rather than a psychological one: the question is whether this particular choice, by this particular person, in these particular circumstances, crossed a line. That is why the two cannot be mapped onto each other, and why the sentence "greed is a mortal sin" is not quite right in either direction.

The three conditions

The tradition settled on three tests, and all three have to be met at once:

  1. Serious matter - the act itself has to be grave, not trivial.
  2. Full knowledge - the person has to know it is wrong; ignorance, even culpable ignorance, changes the assessment.
  3. Deliberate consent - the choice has to be free, not the product of coercion, panic, addiction or force.

The third condition is where most real cases get interesting, and where the pastoral tradition is far more careful than its reputation suggests. Habit, compulsion and fear were all treated as diminishing consent. A person who does something terrible while terrified is not, in this framework, in the same position as a person who plans it calmly.

Where the distinction comes from

It is built on 1 John 5:16-17, which distinguishes between a sin that leads to death and a sin that does not - a passage that is shorter and more enigmatic than the entire later system built on it. The three conditions were worked out over centuries of practice, and they are stated explicitly in the Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraphs 1857 to 1861, which also lists what counts as grave matter.

The important thing to notice is the direction of the reasoning. Scripture provides a distinction; the church supplied the machinery for applying it. That is the same pattern as the seven sins list itself, which also came from later writers organising material rather than from a single text.

How they interact in practice

Capital vices matter because they make mortal sins more likely. A habit of greed does not require a dramatic act of theft - but it does make a person more willing to sign the thing they should not sign. That is the actual purpose of the list: not to rank sins, but to describe the conditions under which a person gradually becomes capable of things they would have rejected ten years earlier.

If you came here looking for which of the seven is yours, the test on the front page scores all seven against each other in twenty questions.

Questions people ask about

What is the difference between a mortal sin and a deadly sin?

A deadly sin is one of the seven capital vices - a habit or disposition that other faults grow out of. A mortal sin is a single act serious enough, and deliberate enough, to break a person's relationship with God. You can have a greedy character without committing a mortal sin, and you can commit one without being a particularly greedy person.

What are the three conditions for a mortal sin?

Serious matter (the act has to be grave in itself), full knowledge (you know it is wrong), and deliberate consent (you freely choose it). All three are required. If any one is missing, the tradition treats it as venial rather than mortal.

Where does the mortal and venial distinction come from?

It is built on 1 John 5:16-17, which distinguishes a sin that leads to death from one that does not. The three conditions were worked out over centuries of pastoral practice and are stated explicitly in the Catechism of the Catholic Church (1857-1861).

Are all seven deadly sins mortal sins?

No. The seven are called capital or deadly because they are sources - the Latin caput means head - not because each occurrence is grave. Pride as a habit is deadly in the sense of being a root; a particular proud remark is probably venial. The confusion comes from the word deadly carrying two meanings.

Not sure yet? Take the test.

The quiz scores all seven sins at once and shows the full ranking, so you can see the runner-up as well as the winner.

Start the 7 deadly sins test

Keep reading