Which Deadly Sin
The seven, entry V

Gluttony as a Deadly Sin

The sin of never letting a good thing stop, whether that thing is food, drink, or something you scroll.

Gluttony is the one on the list that has been almost completely absorbed by medicine. We still talk about pride, envy and anger in moral language; gluttony we talk about in numbers. That is a real change, and it makes the older treatment of it more useful than it first appears, because the old writers were not interested in the body at all.

What the word used to mean

In Latin, gula: an immoderate appetite for food and drink. Aquinas, following Gregory the Great, was unusually specific, and his list is worth reading in full because it is not about quantity: eating too soon (before the proper time), too expensively, too much, too eagerly, and too fussily - that last one meaning the appetite that cannot be satisfied without elaborate conditions.

Four of the five have nothing to do with how much is eaten. The sin is the relationship between a person and their appetite, which is why the tradition insists that a thin person can be gluttonous and a heavy person need not be. It also explains why fasting was prescribed as the remedy: not to punish the body, but to prove to yourself that the appetite can be told no.

The punishment Dante invented for it

The gluttonous stand on the sixth terrace of Mount Purgatory, wasted almost to bone, beneath a fruit tree that smells of food they cannot reach and beside a stream they cannot drink from. Every time they stretch toward it, something turns them back. The punishment is the appetite held permanently one inch from satisfaction, which is a more accurate description of the vice than any sermon manages.

It sits directly below the terrace of lust and above that of greed in Dante's arrangement. Three appetites in a row, deliberately: he wants the reader to see that they are the same machinery aimed at different objects.

What it looks like now

Food is the least interesting version of it. The structure - an appetite that has stopped being consulted with, satisfied in conditions designed to make sure it never quite finishes - is now the standard design of most of what is on a phone. A bag of crisps and a feed are engineered by the same logic.

The practical question the tradition leaves is a good one, and it is not about content: when did you last stop something at the point you had decided to stop, rather than at the point it ran out.

Questions people ask about gluttony

What does gluttony actually mean as a deadly sin?

In Latin, gula: an immoderate appetite for food and drink. Aquinas broke it into five specific failures - eating too soon, too expensively, too much, too eagerly, or too fussily - which is a more precise list than the modern shorthand of eating too much.

What is gluttony's punishment in Dante?

On the sixth terrace of Mount Purgatory the gluttonous stand beneath a fruit tree they can smell but cannot reach, next to a stream they cannot drink, and are themselves wasted almost to skin and bone. The punishment is the appetite held permanently at the edge of satisfaction.

Is gluttony about weight?

No, and the tradition is explicit about it. It is about the relation between a person and their appetite, which is why someone thin can be gluttonous and someone heavy need not be. The sin is the loss of the ability to stop, not the number on a scale.

Is gluttony still counted today?

Less than the others. It has largely dropped out of moral language and been handed to medicine as a health matter - which the old writers would have found strange, since they treated it as a question of self-command rather than a question of the body's size.

Not sure yet? Take the test.

The quiz scores all seven sins at once and shows the full ranking, so you can see the runner-up as well as the winner.

Start the 7 deadly sins test

Keep reading