Which Deadly Sin
The seven, entry IV

Envy as a Deadly Sin

The only sin nobody enjoys: it does not want the thing, it wants the other person not to have it.

Envy is the only one of the seven that offers nothing. Greed at least gets the money, gluttony gets the meal, sloth gets the rest. Envy gets a feeling, and the feeling is unpleasant by definition, because the whole content of it is that somebody else has something good.

What the word used to mean

In Latin, invidia: sorrow at another's good. The definition is almost too neat, and it is what makes the sin easy to spot once you know what you are looking for. It is not wanting what they have. It is being bothered that they have it, and specifically being bothered in a way that makes their loss feel like it would help.

Aquinas put envy close to hatred rather than to desire, because its object is the other person's loss rather than your own gain. He also distinguished it from jealousy, which is about something you already possess and fear losing - a distinction the modern language has more or less dropped, which is a loss, because the two need completely different remedies.

The punishment Dante invented for it

The envious sit on the second terrace of Mount Purgatory with their eyes sewn shut with iron wire, leaning on each other, and the terrace wall is carved with examples of generosity that they cannot see. It is the most pointed punishment in the whole poem. People who spent their lives measuring other people's lives are given the one condition in which measuring is impossible.

Dante also has them lean on one another and sing, which is a detail worth noticing: the remedy for the vice is contact, not separation.

What it looks like now

Envy used to require proximity - a neighbour, a colleague, someone you could see. Now it is delivered, ranked, and repeated all day. The modern shape is not a dramatic coveting of anyone's life; it is the low-grade flattening that happens after twenty minutes of other people's best moments, where your own afternoon suddenly needs a reason to justify itself.

The practical tell the old writers gave is still the best one: notice who you are quietly pleased to hear bad news about. That reaction is not a character flaw you have, it is a diagnosis, and it points directly at what you believe you are owed.

Questions people ask about envy

What does envy actually mean as a deadly sin?

In Latin, invidia: sorrow at another person's good. Not wanting what they have, but being bothered that they have it. That is why the tradition called it the one sin with no pleasure attached - the envious person gets nothing out of it.

What is envy's punishment in Dante?

On the second terrace of Mount Purgatory, the envious have their eyes sewn shut with iron wire. They spent their lives looking at what other people had, so they lose the ability to look at all, and the terrace wall is carved with examples of generosity they cannot see.

Is envy the same as jealousy?

Usually not, though the words are used interchangeably. Jealousy is about something you already have and fear losing. Envy is about something someone else has and you do not. Only one of the two wishes the other person harm.

Why is envy considered worse than greed?

Aquinas argued it is closer to hatred than to desire, because its object is the other person's loss rather than your own gain. Greed wants more; envy wants the comparison to fail, which is why the cure is not getting the thing but being honestly glad for someone.

Not sure yet? Take the test.

The quiz scores all seven sins at once and shows the full ranking, so you can see the runner-up as well as the winner.

Start the 7 deadly sins test

Keep reading