Which Deadly Sin
The seven, entry I

Pride as a Deadly Sin

The sin that needs no object, and the one the old writers kept putting first: reaching for a height that is not yours.

Pride is the one sin that needs no object. The other six all want something outside you: money, a body, someone else's good fortune, food, the person who wronged you, a task you keep avoiding. Pride works with nothing but the self. That is why the writers who built this list kept putting it first, and why it is the hardest of the seven to notice in yourself.

What the word used to mean

In Latin, superbia did not mean feeling good about your work. It meant reaching for a height that is not yours. Gregory the Great, writing around the year 590, treated pride as the queen of the vices and the root from which the other six grow, so a person who is proud in the specific way he means will also be greedy, envious and angry, because all of those are pride looking for something to feed on. Thomas Aquinas later made the reasoning more careful: pride is a disordered appetite for excellence, and it becomes deadly when it turns into contempt for God or for other people.

The distinction that matters practically is the one between confidence and pride. Confidence is about what you can do. Pride is about where you sit relative to everyone else. You can be proud of a piece of work without pride in this sense; the tell is what happens when someone else does the same work better.

The punishment Dante invented for it

Dante's Purgatorio is the best description anyone ever wrote of what pride feels like from the inside, because he made the punishment a physical version of the sin. On the first terrace of the mountain, the proud walk bent double under enormous stones. The soul who spent a lifetime holding their head above everyone else cannot lift it at all. The stone is not torture for its own sake; it is the posture of humility, imposed until it stops being a posture.

Before the souls arrive, the terrace wall is carved with examples of humility, and Dante has to stoop to look at them, which means the reader is doing the same thing the proud are being taught to do. It is a very precise piece of engineering.

What it looks like now

Pride has not changed, only its vocabulary. It is the need to be the one who was right in a meeting that ended three days ago. It is correcting a small factual error in a story someone is telling, because leaving it alone would cost more than the interruption is worth. It is reading a review of your own work and going straight to the sentence that is slightly critical. It is being unable to say “I don't know” without adding a clause that protects you.

The reason it is worth taking seriously is not moral. Pride is expensive. It keeps you in arguments you have already lost, it makes you defensive about feedback that would help you, and it makes you hide the gaps in what you know until they become a problem you cannot hide.

How it interacts with the other six

Pride is rarely alone. Envy is pride comparing itself to someone and finding the comparison unacceptable. Wrath is pride that has been injured and wants the injury acknowledged. Greed is pride keeping score in a currency everyone can see. The old moralists' claim that pride is the root is not a metaphor; it is a description of how the other six get their energy.

If your result was pride, the useful next question is not “am I arrogant?” but “what would I have to give up if I stopped needing to be right?” The second question has an answer you can act on.

Questions people ask about pride

What does pride actually mean as a deadly sin?

In Latin, superbia: a disordered appetite for your own excellence, and specifically the belief that you are above other people rather than merely good at something. The old writers treated it as the root of the other six vices.

What is pride's punishment in Dante?

On the first terrace of Mount Purgatory, the proud walk bent double under heavy stones. Dante built the punishment out of the sin itself: the people who could never bow their heads are made to do it until it stops being a performance.

Is pride the same as confidence?

Not exactly. Confidence is about what you can do. Pride is about where you sit relative to other people, and the test is what happens when someone does the same thing better than you do.

Why is pride called the root of the other sins?

Gregory the Great, writing around 590, treated pride as the queen of the vices and the source of the other six. Envy is pride comparing badly; wrath is pride injured; greed is pride keeping score in public.

Not sure yet? Take the test.

The quiz scores all seven sins at once and shows the full ranking, so you can see the runner-up as well as the winner.

Start the 7 deadly sins test

Keep reading